Straight Line Kohl Eye Pencil

This gorgeous, creamy, dual-sided pencil eyeliner goes on effortlessly in just one swipe for a sexy, smudged bedroom eye (there’s a great sponge tip on one end) or a polished cat eye. Made with mango and meadowfoam-seed oils, it’s nourishing and velvety-smooth. “These are the pencils you see in a makeup artists’ kits—rich, purely pigmented, and the colors are flattering,” says brand founder and NYC makeup artist Rose-Marie Smith.

• HD Black: the ultimate black
• Bronze Definition: a warm bronzy brown
• Plum Definition: a vibrant royal purple