The particular strip of Atlantic Avenue that Diamond Reef inhabits isn’t exactly a tropical oasis, but the tiki-themed cocktails designed by the famous barmen Sam Ross and Michael McIlroy absolutely are. With wood-paneled walls and bright-turquoise booths, the place is what we imagine a mid-century modern party house would look like. The drinks—like the Booze and Juice, a shot paired with fresh Granny Smith apple juice—are playful, and the backyard, which is huge and heated, is a good time almost any time of year. The bar’s version of the classic Penicillin cocktail (honey, lemon, ginger, and scotch), thrown into a slushy machine and renamed the Penichillin, is especially delicious.

You may also like