Wainscott

There's a fierce debate about which of the famed, fist-sized cookies at Levain is their best, but since each one is gooey and served warm, arguing about it seems besides the point. While they also have two locations in the city, the Wainscott store is right along Montauk Highway, making it the perfect spot to pick up a dozen as a housewarming gift on your way into town or a snack for the car on the way home.