Shelter Island Shops
13 Grand Ave., Shelter Island
This lovely shop, which happens to focus strictly on all-natural, USA-made products, recently relocated to a sweet little space on Shelter Island. In addition to Lurk, their house line of organic perfumes, the brand roster isn't particularly deep, with just a few dozen standbys—like May Lindstrom, True Nature Botanicals, and Aster & Bay—but each has been thoroughly vetted by owner/perfumer Anne Nelson Sanford. Dry goods-wise, there's shirting by California Tailor, Shawn Burke bags, and Takara jewelry.